|Season 1, Episode 12|
|First Aired||November 2, 2013|
|Writer(s)||Boyce Bugliari & Jamie McLaughlin|
|Viewed By:||2.4 million viewers|
"Haunted Cookie Jar"
Taylor and Frankie set out to ruin Michelle's date when they mistakenly believe she is dating their school principal.
- Chico Benymon as Ray Preston
- Ginifer King as Michelle Hathaway
- Amber Montana as Taylor Hathaway
- Breanna Yde as Frankie Hathaway
- Curtis Harris as Miles Preston
- Lil' P Nut as Louie Preston
- This is the first episode not to feature Frankie and Louie together.